How to Find Your Perfect Size When Shopping Online

If there’s one thing we miss about our old shop, it’s the fitting room. Back then, finding the right size was easy. You’d try on a sweater, step out, and one of us would say, “Let’s try the next size up,” or “That one’s perfect on you.”

Shopping online takes that moment away. And we know from your messages that sizing is the number one thing that makes online shopping feel uncertain. “Will it fit?” “Should I size up?” “What if it’s too tight across the shoulders?”

So we’ve put together everything we’ve learned about finding the right size from home. With a measuring tape and five minutes, you can order with almost the same confidence you’d have in a fitting room.

Why Sizes Aren’t Always the Same

First, the most important thing to know: a size is not a measurement. A “medium” or a “size 8” can fit very differently from one brand to another, and even from one style to another within the same brand. An oversized sweater is cut to be roomy, a fitted blouse is cut close to the body, and a winter coat is made with extra room for layers underneath.

That’s why the size you usually wear is a good starting point, but the measurements are what really tell you how something will fit.

Body Measurements vs. Garment Measurements

There are two kinds of measurements, and it helps to know the difference.

Body measurements are the measurements of you: your bust, waist, and hips.

Garment measurements are the measurements of the piece itself, laid flat and measured from seam to seam.

Our size charts show garment measurements. That means the bust measurement on the chart is the actual width all the way around the piece, not the body size it’s meant for. A garment should always measure a little larger than your body, so it has room to move.

How to Measure Yourself

All you need is a soft measuring tape. Stand up straight, relax, and keep the tape snug but not tight.

  • Bust: Measure around the fullest part of your chest, keeping the tape level across your back.
  • Waist: Measure around the narrowest part of your waist, usually just above your belly button.
  • Hips: Measure around the widest part of your hips and seat.

Write them down and keep them somewhere handy, like a note on your phone. You’ll use them every time you shop.

The Easiest Trick of All: Measure a Favorite

Here’s the tip we share most often, and it works beautifully.

Take a piece from your closet that fits you just the way you like, say a favorite sweater or a jacket. Lay it flat and measure it the same way our charts do: across the chest from armpit to armpit (then double it), and from the shoulder down to the hem for the length.

Now compare those numbers with our size chart. Whichever size comes closest to your favorite piece is very likely the one for you.

How Much Room Do You Need?

As a general guide:

  • For a relaxed fit, choose a garment about 4 to 6 inches larger than your bust measurement.
  • For an oversized style, your usual size will already be roomy, so check the product description before sizing up.
  • For coats, allow extra room for a sweater underneath.

Finding Your Shoe Size

Shoes can be even trickier, because sizes vary so much between countries and brands. That’s why our footwear size charts are based on foot length.

To measure your foot:

  1. Stand on a sheet of paper with your heel against a wall.
  2. Mark the tip of your longest toe.
  3. Measure from the wall to the mark.
  4. Do both feet, and use the longer measurement.

Our tip: Measure in the evening, when your feet are at their largest after a day of walking.

If you plan to wear thick socks with winter boots, or if your feet are on the wider side, go up half a size.

Read the Fit Notes

On every product page, we include notes on how the piece fits: whether it runs roomy or snug, whether it’s designed to be oversized, and what to do if you’re between sizes. Please give them a quick read before choosing your size. They’re the closest thing we have to standing next to you at the mirror.

When You’re Between Sizes

It happens to all of us. Our general advice:

  • Choose the larger size for tops, sweaters, coats, and shoes. A little extra room is more comfortable than something too tight.
  • Think about how you’ll wear it. Planning to layer? Go up. Prefer a closer fit? Stay with your usual size.
  • When in doubt, ask us. Send us your measurements, and we’ll help you choose.

A Few Final Thoughts

Finding the right size online takes a few extra minutes at first, but once you know your measurements, it becomes second nature. And there’s one big advantage over the fitting room: you can try everything on at home, with your own mirror, your own shoes, and the rest of your closet right there.

If something doesn’t fit the way you hoped, don’t worry. That’s what our 30-day money-back guarantee is for.

Happy shopping, friends. And if you ever have a sizing question, we’re always just a message away.

With love,
Norma & Debbie